90s Heartthrob Left Hollywood and Grew a Gray Beard at 57 after His Ex-wife Started Dating Another Man Shortly after Their Breakup – Pics

Before becoming a household name, he had humble beginnings in Hollywood. One of his earliest uncredited roles was as a background actor in the 1984 film, “The Karate Kid,” where he appeared as a member of Cobra Kai, the group of antagonists.

From these minor roles to his first major public appearance beside his sister in the late ’80s to the silver-haired 57-year-old today, his transformation has been gradual but profound. His journey has included fame, family, and personal reinvention, as seen in photos spanning over three decades.

1992: The ‘Melrose Place’ Breakthrough

In 1992, he landed his career-defining role as Billy Campbell on “Melrose Place.” The show quickly became a prime-time sensation, and his character turned him into one of Hollywood’s rising stars. His clean-cut looks and easygoing charm resonated with audiences, making him a fan favorite on the show.

During this period, the actor was often seen at high-profile events, including the California United Democratic Campaign’s Star-Spangled Caravan Tour, where he sported a patriotic outfit that matched the event’s theme.

With neatly styled, wavy hair and a confident presence, Shue was riding the wave of his newfound fame. His image as a heartthrob was solidified during this time, as he appeared more regularly in public.

1993: At the Height of His Popularity

By 1993, he was one of the hottest stars on television, thanks to his role in “Melrose Place.” His on-screen chemistry with co-star Heather Locklear made them one of TV’s most beloved duos.

Off-screen, his life was equally busy, as he attended numerous high-profile events that cemented his status as a Hollywood heartthrob. His appearances at events such as the 19th Annual People’s Choice Awards and Elton John’s AIDS Foundation Oscar Party in 1993 showcased his evolving style.

Whether he was dressed sharply in tuxedos or sporting more casual looks like denim shirts and khakis, the actor embodied the laid-back charm of the early ’90s. These photos captured a confident young man at the peak of his popularity.

1994: Marriage and Family

In 1994, his personal life took center stage as he married his first wife, Jennifer Hageney, a floral designer. The couple soon started a family and welcomed three sons — Nate, Aidan, and Wyatt.

Despite his growing family commitments, he made public appearances, such as at the Do Something Foundation’s kick-off party in May 1994. Dressed in a sharp suit, he reflected a more polished and mature look as he balanced his career and family responsibilities.

His family was becoming an important aspect of his life, marking a subtle transition from the carefree heartthrob to a more settled family man.

1995-1997: Balancing Fame and Personal Life

During the mid-’90s, the actor, still a central figure on “Melrose Place,” remained a fan favorite, but he was also becoming increasingly involved in philanthropic work.

His passion for giving back was evident through his involvement with the “Do Something” foundation. In 1996, he was seen proudly wearing the Los Angeles Galaxy soccer uniform during a promotional shoot.

His brief stint as a professional soccer player was a testament to his athletic background, blending his love for sports with his Hollywood fame. These years were when he was still in the public eye, balancing multiple roles.

2004-2009: Transitioning Away from Hollywood

By the mid-to-late-2000s, the “Melrose Place” alum had largely stepped away from acting, focusing more on his passions and entrepreneurial ventures. Around this time, he co-founded CaféMom, reflecting his shift from Hollywood heartthrob to internet entrepreneur.

The social networking site is geared towards mothers. His role in building CaféMom underscored his commitment to social causes, much like his earlier work in philanthropy.

During this period, Shue made occasional public appearances. He was seen at Planet Hollywood in New York in 2004 and at the Sundance Film Festival in 2006 with his sister, Elisabeth Shue.

He returned briefly to the screen in 2007 to co-write and star in “Gracie.” His style also became more relaxed and casual, reflecting his evolving focus on family and business rather than the Hollywood spotlight.

On April 7, 2009, Shue attended the book launch event for “Today’s Moms – Essentials for Surviving Baby’s First Year” at Rouge Tomate. He was dressed casually in a brown leather jacket and a black t-shirt. It was during this year that his marriage to Hageney ended.

2010: A Blended Family and New Beginnings

The now-retired actor entered a new chapter of his life in 2010 when he married “Good Morning America” anchor Amy Robach. The marriage brought together their five children from previous marriages, creating a blended family they affectionately called the “ShueBachians.”

His three sons joined Robach’s two daughters, Ava and Annalise, in what appeared to be a happy and supportive family unit. He and Robach were often seen together at various public events, including charity functions and red carpets.

At this point, he had fully transitioned away from acting, focusing on his family and philanthropic efforts, while making occasional media appearances alongside Robach. Photos from this period show a polished and content entrepreneur, enjoying his role as a family man.

2011-2017: Family First with Rare Public Appearances

Between 2011 and 2017, he largely kept out of the public eye. Though his Hollywood days were behind him, he occasionally stepped out for high-profile events.

He was seen attending events such as Us Weekly’s “Most Stylish New Yorkers” in 2014 and The Breast Cancer Research Foundation’s Pink Carpet Party in 2015.

By 2017, the couple’s public outings were infrequent, but they occasionally shared family moments on social media. One memorable post from October 2017 shows the couple with three of their five children enjoying a fall day at a corn maze.

Though he wasn’t in the public eye as much, he remained a devoted father and husband, quietly enjoying his life away from the limelight.

2018-2021: A Quiet but Happy Family Life

Between 2018 and 2021, the couple seemed to enjoy a peaceful family life. The couple often shared glimpses of their blended family on social media, posting photos highlighting their close bond with their children.

In November 2018, the couple attended the Levi’s Times Square Store Opening in New York City, looking like a happy, loving duo. Throughout this period, they continued to appear together at events and posted heartwarming images of their family having fun together, solidifying their image as a united front.

In 2019, Robach and her then-husband still frequently shared pictures of family outings and celebrations, giving their followers a peek into their personal lives. The couple appeared to be thriving and maintaining a strong, united public presence.

Photos posted in 2020 continued to show a happy and close-knit family. The world may have been going through a tumultuous time due to the pandemic, but for the couple, family appeared to be their primary focus.

However, in 2021, during an interview, the former Hollywood star reflected on his time in Hollywood, saying, “The world has changed now. It’s a lot tougher being a celebrity these days. The scrutiny is so much worse.” However, he fondly recalled his time as an actor, adding that he had fun during those years.

These years seemed to be a period of stability and joy for the former actor and his family, with their blended household thriving. But by 2022, the picture-perfect family life took an unexpected turn, changing the dynamic for everyone involved.

2022: The Split and Public Drama

In 2022, Andrew Shue was back in the headlines due to his high-profile split from Robach. Their separation became public just as Robach’s romance with her co-anchor T.J. Holmes made waves in the media.

The affair grabbed significant attention, especially after the couple’s relationship was outed in November 2022, sparking a media frenzy. One Facebook user remarked, “Girl downgraded. I remember him from Melrose Place.”

Throughout the drama, Shue remained notably private, maintaining a low profile as his ex-wife’s relationship with Holmes dominated news outlets. Photos from this time show Shue looking calm and composed despite the attention surrounding his personal life.

Later in the year, Shue was linked to Holmes’ ex-wife, Marilee Fiebig, sparking rumors of a possible romance. The two were seen together on multiple occasions, fueling further media interest.

Fans comments on the pairing included, “They actually fit better. Handsome and Beautiful” and “He is hot!” Despite the media attention, Shue has maintained a low-key presence, staying largely out of the spotlight.

2024: A New Look at 57

Fast forward to 2024, and Shue has taken on a strikingly different appearance from his heartthrob days. Now 57, Shue is sporting a distinguished gray beard and silver hair. The look contrasts with the youthful, clean-cut image he was once known for.

His recent public appearances have showcased his transformation into a more mature, rugged figure, and fans have taken notice. Despite stepping away from Hollywood, Shue continues to captivate public interest, especially with his relationship with Holmes’ ex-wife.

The pair is reportedly still going strong, further intertwining their lives after the public fallout surrounding their former spouses. Shue may no longer be the clean-shaven star of “Melrose Place,” but his evolution demonstrates his ability to adapt and thrive away from the limelight.